Skip to content

NewSheboygan CountyMLS 1987874

335 Caroline St

Plymouth, Wisconsin 53073

$199,900

335 Caroline St, Plymouth, photo 1 of 29
5Bedrooms
2Bathrooms
2,176Square feet
1901Year built

About this home

Full of character near downtown Plymouth! This classic two-story has good bones, generous space, and room to make it your own. Originally a duplex and since converted to single-family: 5 bedrooms (2 main, 3 up), 2 full baths, and 2,176 sq ft. Two full kitchens offer flexibility for guests, extended family, or a hobby space, plus a main-level sun room. Old-house charm includes a bay window, wood clapboard siding, and a fieldstone foundation. High-efficiency forced-air furnace and central air on the main level. The home needs some work and TLC, especially on the exterior, and is priced to reflect it - bring your vision and finishing touches.

Facts & features

Status
For Sale
Property type
Single-Family
Style
Victorian/Federal
Year built
1901
Bedrooms
5
Full baths
2
Finished sq ft
2,176
Lot size
0.18 acres
Garage
3 car
Basement
Full, Block, Sump Pump
Heating
Natural Gas, Forced Air, Wall Furnace
Cooling
Window Unit(s), Central Air
Annual taxes
$2,809 (2025)
School district
Plymouth Joint
County
Sheboygan
Days on market
6
MLS#
1987874
Interior
High Speed Internet
Construction
Wood
Parking
Paved, Parking Space
Lot
Sidewalk
Water
Municipal Water
Sewer
Municipal Sewer
Utilities
Cable TV Available
Zoning
Residential

Location

Estimated monthly payment

$1,362/mo

Principal & interest
$1,011
Property tax
$234
Insurance (estimate)
$117

20% down, 30-year fixed at 6.5%. An estimate, not a loan offer. Change the numbers

Listing courtesy of SUV Properties LLC · Daniel Lasota. Listing information provided by Metro MLS through the Internet Data Exchange program and last updated Nov 10, 2026. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. Copyright 2026 Metro MLS, Inc.