Skip to content

Milwaukee CountyMLS 1899471

4240 W Concordia Ave, 4218

Milwaukee, Wisconsin 53216

$495,000

4240 W Concordia Ave, 4218, Milwaukee: Trinity Presbyterian Good Shepherd
—Bedrooms
—Bathrooms
23,921Square feet
1960Year built

About this home

Iconic Sherman Boulevard Church, a Sherman Park anchor of faith and Outreach for more than 60 years. The Large Sanctuary Capacity 300 plus, includes balcony seating & Offers uplifting atmosphere for meditation and praise.. THERE IS A PIPE ORGAN INCLUDED ! There are common area meeting rooms, class rooms, office space, Fellowship hall with kitchen, Private meeting spaces and enough room for cultivating creative arts and crafts. There is square footage enough to transition this building to an Education Center for the Sherman Park Community. There is a second Sanctuary constructed 1935, it enters from Concordia Avenue. Through the years there have been Additions and Remodeling . Boiler hot water heat is newer. This property is a Sherman Park Treasure

Facts & features

Status
For Sale
Property type
Comm/Industrial
Year built
1960
Finished sq ft
23,921
Lot size
0.67 acres
Basement
Full, Block
County
Milwaukee
Days on market
733
MLS#
1899471
Construction
Low Maintenance Trim, Brick, Stone
Roof
Metal, Composition
Water
Municipal Water
Sewer
Municipal Sewer
Zoning
RT2

Location

Directions: Sherman Boulevard to Concordia Avenue Entire northeast corner is the Church Building from Concordia Avenue to Barnard Place (southeast corner )

Estimated monthly payment

$3,280/mo

Principal & interest
$2,503
Property tax
$660
Insurance (estimate)
$117

20% down, 30-year fixed at 6.5%. An estimate, not a loan offer. Change the numbers

Listing courtesy of Jarvis Realty, Inc · Elwyn Jarvis. Listing information provided by Metro MLS through the Internet Data Exchange program and last updated Oct 22, 2026. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. Copyright 2026 Metro MLS, Inc.